Why the Dwarves Cannot Coordinate After Bilbo Cuts Them Free

Bilbo cuts a weakened Dwarf free from giant spider webs among the dark branches of Mirkwood.

Bilbo Baggins has done what seems almost impossible. Deep in Mirkwood, he has found his captured companions, driven away enormous spiders, and begun cutting the Dwarves out of their silken prisons. Yet the rescue immediately reveals another problem. The Dwarves are no longer securely bound, but they cannot simply gather themselves into an effective fighting … Read more

How Thuringwethil’s Form Lets Luthien Exploit Angband’s Own Recognition System

Lúthien in Thuringwethil's bat-winged form flies above Beren disguised as Draugluin on the desolate approach to Angband.

At the gates of Angband, where Morgoth guarded the Silmarils beneath the mountains of Thangorodrim, Lúthien faced a problem that courage alone could not solve. How could an Elven princess and a mortal Man approach the greatest fortress of the Enemy without being destroyed before reaching its master? The answer lay partly in something deeply … Read more

What Riding Outside the Barrels Costs Bilbo That the Dwarves Avoid

Bilbo Baggins clings to the outside of a wooden barrel on the cold Forest River while sealed barrels carrying the Dwarves float nearby beneath the dark trees of Mirkwood.

When Bilbo Baggins escapes the Elvenking’s halls in *The Hobbit*, he achieves something remarkable: he gets thirteen imprisoned Dwarves out of captivity without openly fighting their guards. Yet the escape contains a cruel little irony. The Dwarves are shut inside wooden barrels, unable to see where they are going or do anything to help themselves. … Read more