Why Grishnakh Searches the Hobbits Himself

Grishnákh watching the captive Merry and Pippin suspiciously in the Orc camp near Fangorn

Merry and Pippin are surrounded by enemies near Fangorn, trapped inside a ring of armed Orcs while the Riders of Rohan wait outside. Their captors have orders, commanders, and competing loyalties. Yet the moment that finally gives the hobbits their chance does not come from any organized rescue. It comes from one Orc deciding that … Read more

Why Bilbo Leaps Over Gollum Instead of Killing Him

Bilbo Baggins prepares to leap over Gollum rather than kill him in a dark tunnel beneath the Misty Mountains.

Deep beneath the Misty Mountains, Bilbo Baggins has something almost no one in Middle-earth would blame him for using: an invisible advantage over an enemy who intends him harm. Gollum crouches between Bilbo and the way out. Bilbo has Sting. Gollum is unarmed. More importantly, Bilbo has accidentally discovered that the strange ring in his … Read more

Why Boromir Does Not Report Galadriel’s Offer Clearly to the Others

Galadriel searches the hearts of Boromir and the Fellowship beneath the golden mallorn trees of Lothlórien.

When the Fellowship enters Lothlórien, Galadriel does something far more unsettling than simply welcome them. She looks into each member of the Company and tests what lies within. Later, the companions compare what they experienced. Sam admits that he felt exposed and confronted with the possibility of abandoning the Quest for something he deeply wanted. … Read more