Why Some of Sauron’s Soldiers Flee While Others Keep Fighting

Sauron’s mixed army faltering at the Black Gate as his controlling will turns away from the battlefield

At the Black Gate, Sauron’s army seems overwhelming. Orcs, Trolls, Easterlings, Southrons, and other servants of Mordor have surrounded a vastly smaller Host of the West. Then, far behind the battlefield, the One Ring falls into the fire of Mount Doom. What happens next is stranger than a simple military rout. Some of Sauron’s servants … Read more

The long betrothal of Aldarion and Erendis exposes incompatible political duties

Aldarion and Erendis standing above the distant sea during their long courtship in Númenor.

Aldarion and Erendis: The Long Betrothal That Exposed an Impossible Conflict of Duties Aldarion loved the Sea. Erendis loved Aldarion. That sounds like the beginning of a simple romantic tragedy, but in Númenor nothing about their relationship remained simple for long. Aldarion was not merely a restless sailor who preferred ships to home. He was … Read more

Why Gandalf and Pippin Cross the Druadan Forest Road at Night

Gandalf and Pippin racing through Anórien at night on Shadowfax beside the dark Drúadan country

Pippin wakes to darkness, rushing wind, and the relentless movement of Shadowfax beneath him. Somewhere behind lies Isengard and the terrible mistake of looking into the palantír. Somewhere ahead stands Minas Tirith. Between them stretches Anórien, the eastern land of Gondor beneath the White Mountains. Then fire appears on the hills. At first Pippin does … Read more

How Rivendell’s fate depends on Elrond’s departure but is not dated precisely

Elrond overlooking Rivendell near the end of the Third Age as evening settles over the hidden valley.

Rivendell feels like the kind of place that should survive forever. When Bilbo first reaches the hidden valley in The Hobbit, it is already ancient. When Frodo arrives generations later, the Last Homely House still seems almost untouched by the decay consuming the wider world. Songs, stories, healing, memory, and counsel endure there while kingdoms … Read more

Why the Fellowship Reaches Lothlorien Without Being Able to Simply Walk In

The Fellowship encounters Haldir and the Galadhrim at the guarded northern edge of Lothlórien after escaping Moria.

When the Fellowship escapes Moria, Lothlórien seems almost close enough to touch. Aragorn knows where they must go. Legolas recognizes the country. Beyond the cold streams and winter woods lies one of the last great Elven refuges in Middle-earth. Yet reaching its trees does not mean being admitted. This is one of the easily overlooked … Read more