Why Marching Speed Quietly Controls So Much of Tolkien’s Plot

Chasing the Uruk-hai across Rohan

When people talk about what drives The Lord of the Rings, they usually name the obvious forces first. The Ring.Providence.Courage.Mercy.Despair.Pride. All of those matter. But Tolkien repeatedly builds his plot on something far less dramatic on the surface: how quickly people can move through the world. Not in a modern, mechanical sense. Middle-earth does not run … Read more

Why the Witch-king Didn’t Bring the Full Might of Angmar Against Rivendell Earlier

Angmar war against Arnor

At first glance, the question feels simple. If the Witch-king of Angmar was building a northern war against the heirs of Isildur, and if Rivendell was the chief refuge of Elrond in Eriador, why not strike Imladris first and hardest? Why spend generations tearing at Arnor, corrupting Rhudaur, breaking Cardolan, and grinding down Arthedain before … Read more